· Draft

Who Should Take Over Your Business?

The right person to take over your business can do the job and wants the job. And your team will follow them.

The right person to take over your business is someone who can do the job, wants the job, and whom your team will follow. That may be a son or daughter. It may be your top manager, a group from your team, a partner, or an outside buyer. Whoever it is, they should be able to make the calls you make today. Pricing, hiring, the bank, the hard customers. Love for the business is not enough, and neither is skill alone. You need both, plus the trust of your people.

One more thing before you pick. Who runs your business next and who owns it next are two separate questions. Your daughter might own it while your manager runs it. Your crew lead might run it for years before he can afford to own it. Answer each question on its own.

What are your options for who takes over?

Most owners have six options. Each one asks for different work first.

  1. Family. A son, daughter, niece or in-law takes over. This works when they have the skills and truly want it, not just because they feel they should.
  2. A key employee. Your top manager, foreman or office lead. They know the work and the team. They may need years to learn the money side.
  3. A group from your team. Two or three of your people take over together. Often they buy in over time. A buy-in means they buy part of the business, often in steps, while you still own the rest.
  4. A partner. If you co-own the business, your partner may buy your part. This is easiest when you agreed the terms early.
  5. An outside buyer. Another owner, a competitor or a bigger company. A business broker usually finds and screens them.
  6. A hired manager. You keep owning the business and hire someone to run it day to day.

In the Exit Planning Institute's 2023 survey of owners, 70% said they knew all their exit options. Ten years earlier, only 34% did. Knowing the options is the easy part. Picking the person is harder.

How do you evaluate a possible successor?

Use five tests. Score each person you are thinking about, side by side.

Test

What to look for

How to check

They want it

They ask for more, not less. They talk about the business on their own time.

Ask them straight out. Then watch what they do for six months.

They can do it

They can price, plan, hire and read the numbers, or can learn fast.

Hand them one real piece of the job and see how it goes.

The team follows them

People bring them problems without being told to.

Go away for a week. See who the team turns to.

Customers trust them

Your top customers know them and are fine dealing with them.

Bring them into the next three big customer meetings.

They can own it

They can carry the risk, the debt and the stress of owning.

Talk it through. Your CPA can help with the money side.

No one scores perfectly. A person who passes the first three tests can usually learn the other two. A person who fails "they want it" rarely works out, no matter how skilled.

In 2025 the City of Cambridge put out a toolkit for small business owners. Its checklist for leaders asks much the same things. Can your managers "manage daily operations without owner involvement?" Are they "willing to take on ownership or higher responsibility?" Those two questions do a lot of the work.

How do you test someone before you decide?

Give them a real piece of the business, with real authority, for a full season. Not a task. A whole area. Pricing all jobs under a set size. Running the schedule. Handling the bank.

Then step back. Do not fix their mistakes for them. Talk about them each week. You will learn more in three months of this than in three years of guessing.

The Cambridge toolkit suggests picking out high-potential people three to five years before the handover. That gives you time for a few seasons of real tests, and time to change your mind.

What about skills they do not have yet?

That is normal. Most good successors are strong on the work and weak on the money, or the other way round. This is where leadership development comes in. Pair them with you on the decisions they have not made before. Get them time with your CPA. Write down the institutional knowledge, the things only you know, so they do not have to guess. That writing-down is called knowledge capture. Start with the critical positions, the roles the business cannot do without for a week.

Should the business stay in the family?

Only if a family member can pass the five tests, and wants to. Many owners hope a child will take over. In a family-owned business, that hope is strong.

Most owners lean that way. In EPI's 2023 survey, 60% of owners who started their business wanted to hand it on inside, to family or the team. For owners who took it over from a parent, it was 82%. Once a business has been handed down, owners lean even harder toward keeping it inside.

But keeping it in the family raises its own questions. What about children who do not work in the business? Is it fair if one child gets the company? These are real, and they need talking through early. Our guide to family business succession planning covers them in more depth.

What if no one inside is right?

Then you have three good options.

  • Hire a general manager. You keep owning the business, and an outside pro runs it. This buys you time to decide later.
  • Sell to an outside buyer. A business broker finds buyers, checks they are serious, and runs the sale. See how to sell a small business.
  • Sell to your team over time. Even if no one person is ready, a small group may be. They can buy in slowly while they grow into the roles.

Many inside buyers cannot pay all at once. So the price is often paid over time, sometimes tied to how the business does after you leave. That last kind is called an earn-out. The terms are your lawyer's and your CPA's job, not something to sketch on a napkin.

Whoever you pick, the people under them matter just as much. A new leader with no team is stuck. Read how to keep your key people through the change.

For example

This is a made-up example. It is not a client.

Frank owns an electrical company with 20 people. His son, Jake, works in the office but has never run a job. His foreman, Sam, has been with him twelve years. The crews would follow Sam anywhere, but Sam has never seen the books.

Frank scores both on the five tests. Jake wants it and customers like him, but the crews do not turn to him yet. Sam passes on the work, the team and the customers. He has never thought about owning.

So Frank splits the question. Sam takes over running the field this year, with all job pricing. Jake takes over the books and the bank, and sits with the CPA each quarter. In two years, Frank will look again. Maybe Sam runs it and Jake owns it. Maybe they buy in together. Either way, Frank is choosing with facts, not hopes.

What mistakes do owners make when picking a successor?

  • Picking out of guilt. The child who "should" take it is not always the one who wants it.
  • Picking your top worker by default. Your top tech may not want to manage people. Doing the job and running the business are different skills.
  • Never testing them. A title with no real authority proves nothing.
  • Waiting too long to tell them. People cannot get ready for a job they do not know is coming.
  • Leaving the team out. If your crews or front desk do not trust the new leader, good people leave.

What we look at

Altus Financial is a business coaching firm in Northampton, MA. Choosing who runs it next is part of how we look at Transfer.

In Discovery, we help you map who does what today, who could step up, and what each person would need to learn. Then we help you set up the real tests, and check how they are going. An outside coach or consultant helps here for a plain reason: it is hard to judge your own child and your own foreman fairly.

Picking a person is one step in a bigger plan. Before you choose, check is your business ready to run without you. For the whole map, see how to plan who runs it next.

Your lawyer writes the deal. Your CPA handles the tax. A business broker runs any outside sale. We work alongside them on the business itself.

Weighing who should take over? Book a Founders Call. It takes 20 to 30 minutes.

Sources

  1. 70% of owners in 2023 report being aware of all their exit options, vs 34% in 2013 Exit Planning Institute, 2023 National State of Owner Readiness Report
  2. 82% of second-generation owners favor an internal exit option; 60% of first-generation owners favored it Exit Planning Institute, 2023 National State of Owner Readiness Report
  3. Leadership Readiness Checklist: "Can leadership manage daily operations without owner involvement?" and "Are key leaders willing to take on ownership or higher responsibility?" City of Cambridge, Succession Planning Toolkit (April 2025), Tool 4
  4. Identify high-potential employees for leadership roles 3–5 years before transition City of Cambridge, Succession Planning Toolkit (April 2025), Tool 5 Leadership Development Roadmap

Questions

Frequently asked.

Who should take over my business when I step back?

Someone who can do the job, wants the job, and has your team behind them. That might be a family member, a key employee, a group from your team, a partner, or an outside buyer. Test them with a real piece of the business before you decide. Skill without desire rarely works.

How do I choose between my child and my top employee?

Score both on the same tests: do they want it, can they do it, will the team follow, do customers trust them, and can they own it. You may not have to choose. One can run the business while the other owns it, or they can share the roles.

Should I tell a possible successor they are being considered?

Usually, yes, once you are fairly sure. People cannot get ready for a job they do not know is coming. Be clear that it is a trial, not a promise. Give them a real area to run, and talk about how it is going each week.

What if no one in my business can take over?

You still have options. You can hire a general manager and keep owning the business. You can sell to an outside buyer through a business broker. Or a small group from your team can buy in over time while they grow into the roles. Your lawyer and CPA set the terms.

How early should I pick a successor?

Start looking three to five years before you plan to step back. That gives you time to test more than one person, train the one you pick, and change your mind if it is not working. A City of Cambridge toolkit for small businesses uses the same three-to-five-year window.

Keep Reading

Talk to a consultant

Got a question about your own business?

Start with a short call. It takes 20 to 30 minutes, and we both work out if we can help.

Important information

The content on this website is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended as, and should not be relied upon as, legal, tax, accounting, or investment advice.

Individual circumstances vary. You should consult your own attorney and CPA before acting on any information presented here. Altus Financial does not draft legal documents, give legal advice, or render tax or accounting opinions.