· Draft

How to Hire and Keep Good People

To hire and keep good people, be clear about the job, test for it, and then manage people well once they start. Many people who quit could have been kept.

To hire and keep good people, be clear about the job, test for it, and then manage people well once they start. Many people who quit could have been kept. In a 2024 Gallup study, 42% of people who quit a job said their manager or company could have done something to keep them.

Hiring and keeping people are one job, not two. Keeping people is called retention. A poor hire quits fast. A good hire with no one to talk to quits slower. This guide covers both, in the order they happen.

How do you hire better employees?

You hire better employees by deciding what good looks like first, then testing for it. Many hiring mistakes happen before the first interview, when the job is still fuzzy.

1. Write down the job. Not a list of duties. Write what this person should have done well 90 days in. "Runs a service call start to finish with no callbacks" is clearer than "HVAC tech, 3 years' experience."

2. Say the hard parts out loud. Tell people about the early starts, the hot attics or the busy Monday phones. The ones who stay in the running after that are more likely to stay in the job.

3. Test the real work. Pay for a short working interview, a ride-along, or a small task. Watching someone do the work beats hearing them talk about it.

4. Ask everyone the same questions. This is called a structured interview. You use the same questions for every person and score the answers the same way. The U.S. Office of Personnel Management notes that interviews with more structure do a better job of predicting how someone will do on the job.

5. Call references, and ask real questions. "Would you hire them again?" tells you more than "Did they work there?"

A good question for any role: "Tell me about a time a job went wrong. What did you do?" Listen for whether they own it or blame someone else.

Where do you find good people?

Good people often come through people who already know you. Your own team is often your first source. Ask them who they would want to work beside.

Other places to look:

  • Trade schools and training programs. Build a link with one or two teachers.
  • Past applicants. The person you almost hired last spring may be ready now.
  • Customers and suppliers. They see good workers at other shops.
  • Your name in town. People talk about where it is good to work, and where it is not.

That last one takes years to build and weeks to lose. How you treat the people you have is your hiring ad.

What does it cost when someone quits?

When someone quits, you pay to replace them, and you lose what they knew. Gallup estimates the cost of replacing someone at about 40% of a year's pay for frontline staff. It puts the cost at 80% for people in technical roles, and about 200% for leaders and managers.

Those are estimates across many firms, not your number. But the costs are real in any business:

  • Time spent on job ads, calls and interviews.
  • Overtime for the people covering the gap.
  • Weeks or months before the new person is up to speed.
  • Mistakes and redo work while they learn.
  • Customers who notice a new face, or a missed call.

There is also labor cost to think about. Your labor cost is what you pay for all the hours worked, plus the labor burden. Labor burden is the extra cost on top of pay, like payroll taxes. Your CPA or payroll service can show you what yours is. When people turn over, you pay that full cost for hours that produce less.

Then there is the know-how. When a long-time tech or office manager leaves, the business loses institutional knowledge. That means the things that "everyone knows" but no one wrote down. Which customer wants a call first. Which supplier is always late. How the old system really works.

How do you reduce employee turnover?

You cut turnover by talking with people about their future. Start them well, and fix what makes them leave. In the same Gallup study, 45% of people who quit said no boss had talked with them about their job or their future. That was in the three months before they left.

That fix costs little. These steps tend to help:

  • Plan the first 90 days. Who trains them? What should they know by week one, week four and week twelve? The first few weeks set the tone.
  • Hold short one-on-one talks. Once a month, ask: How is it going? What gets in your way? Where do you want to be in two years?
  • Show a path. A helper can become a lead. A lead can become a manager. Building people up this way is called leadership development, and it gives people a reason to stay.
  • Check your pay against the local market. You don't have to be the highest payer. But if you are well below, people will leave for a small raise.
  • Respect their time. Steady schedules, fair on-call turns, and leaving on time when you can.
  • Fix the bad manager. If people keep quitting the same lead, the problem may be the lead.

Pay attention to your critical positions. These are the few roles where one person leaving would stall the business. Know who your key people are, and talk with them first. If you are planning a sale or handover, read our guide to keep your key people through it.

How do you hold employees accountable?

You hold people to the job by agreeing on what done looks like. Then you track it, and check it at a set time. Accountability is a clear promise, a number that shows it, and a set time to look.

Step

What it looks like

Set the standard

"Every job gets photos and a signed sheet before the truck leaves."

Pick the number

Share of jobs with photos and a signed sheet this week.

Check it on a set day

Friday, ten minutes, with the lead.

Follow up fast

Same week, in private, calm and specific.

Be fair

Same rule for your newest hire and your longest-serving tech.

Often, what gets called a "bad attitude" is really a fuzzy standard. People can't hit a target they have never seen. Write it down first.

When someone still misses after clear warnings, act. Keeping one person who won't do the work tells everyone else the standard is optional. Before you discipline or let anyone go, talk to your lawyer about how to document it. Your lawyer can also look over an employee handbook.

A worked example

For example, picture a dental office with two front desk staff. This is an invented example, not a client. The office has hired five people for those two seats in two years. Each one left within six months. The schedule has gaps, and the phones go to voicemail.

So they start by writing what good looks like at 90 days. The schedule is full a week ahead. Calls get picked up by the third ring. The end-of-day close is done right. They add a paid half-day working interview, so applicants see the Monday rush before they say yes.

The new hire gets a 90-day plan and a weekly talk with the office manager. They track two numbers: open slots in next week's schedule, and missed calls. Six months later, both front desk staff are still there. That is not a promise. It is what the steps are built to do.

What we look at

When we look at Growth, people are often the real limit. A firm can't grow faster than it can hire, train and keep good people. You can read how we look at Growth.

In Discovery, we look at who you have, who you need next, and where people leave. In Alignment, we meet each month to keep the hiring plan moving and check how your team is doing. Read about ongoing coaching in Alignment.

If you are close to needing a manager, read when to hire your first manager. And if you want to see what each hire must bring in, start with your profit per job.

Your lawyer handles the handbook, discipline and firing paperwork. Your CPA or payroll service handles pay and payroll taxes.

Talk it through

Altus Financial is a business coaching firm in Northampton, MA. We work with all kinds of service firms. Some are dental and orthodontic practices. Some are trade firms.

If hiring is eating your evenings, talk it through with us. A Founders Call takes 20 to 30 minutes. Book a Founders Call.

Sources

  1. 42% of employees who voluntarily left say their manager or organization could have done something to prevent it Gallup, "42% of Employee Turnover Is Preventable but Often Ignored" (July 9, 2024)
  2. 45% of voluntary leavers say neither a manager nor another leader discussed their job satisfaction, performance or future with them in the three months before leaving Gallup, same article (July 9, 2024)
  3. Replacement cost estimates: about 40% of salary for frontline employees, 80% for technical professionals, 200% for leaders and managers Gallup, same article (July 9, 2024)
  4. Interviews with higher degrees of structure show higher levels of validity U.S. Office of Personnel Management, "Structured Interviews"

Questions

Frequently asked.

How do I hire better employees for a small business?

Decide what good looks like 90 days into the job, then test for it. Tell people the hard parts up front. Pay for a short working interview or ride-along. Ask every person the same questions and score them the same way. Then call references and ask whether they would hire the person again.

How do I reduce employee turnover?

Talk with people about their future, not just their tasks. Plan their first 90 days and meet one-on-one each month. Show a path to a bigger role, check your pay against the local market, and respect their time. If people keep leaving the same lead, look hard at that lead.

How do I hold employees accountable without being the bad guy?

Agree on what done looks like, pick a number that shows it, and check it at a set time each week. Follow up fast, in private, and treat everyone the same. Often, a missed standard was a fuzzy one. When someone still misses after clear warnings, ask your lawyer how to document it.

How much does it cost to replace an employee?

Gallup estimates it at about 40% of a year's pay for frontline staff, 80% for technical roles and 200% for leaders and managers. Those are averages, not your number. Your own cost includes hiring time, overtime to cover the gap, training, and the know-how that walks out the door.

Where do small businesses find good employees?

Good hires often come through people who already know you. Ask your team who they would want to work beside. Build links with trade schools, keep in touch with past applicants, and listen to customers and suppliers. How you treat your current people shapes your name in town.

Keep Reading

Talk to a consultant

Got a question about your own business?

Start with a short call. It takes 20 to 30 minutes, and we both work out if we can help.

Important information

The content on this website is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended as, and should not be relied upon as, legal, tax, accounting, or investment advice.

Individual circumstances vary. You should consult your own attorney and CPA before acting on any information presented here. Altus Financial does not draft legal documents, give legal advice, or render tax or accounting opinions.