Reviewed

When to Hire Your First Manager

Hire your first manager when you have become the thing that slows the business down. Where your hours go matters more than how many people you have.

Man holding cardboard sign with the word “hiring” written on it

Hire your first manager when you have become the thing that slows the business down. If jobs wait on your answer, if you fix the same problems every week, and if the work only you can do keeps slipping, it is time. How many people you have matters less than where your hours go.

Many owners wait too long. They hire a manager after they are worn out, not before. This guide gives you the signs, the traps, and a plan for the first few months.

What are the signs you need a manager?

You need a manager when the business can't move faster than you can answer questions. Look for these signs:

  • Your phone runs your day. Crews, staff and customers call you first, for small things and big ones.
  • Work waits on you. Quotes sit for days. Jobs stall until you sign off.
  • The same fires keep coming back. You fix a problem, and next week it's back.
  • Your own work gets pushed aside. Pricing, sales, cash and planning wait until late at night, or never.
  • Your key people are leaving. They don't get time with you, and no one else can answer them.
  • You can't take a week off. When you try, things break.

If three or more of these sound like your week, you are likely past the point where one person can hold it all.

Is it too early to hire a manager?

It is too early if you can't say what the manager would own. A manager hired to "help out" ends up as one more person who asks you questions.

Wait, or get ready first, if:

  • Nothing is written down. A new manager can't run a way of working that only lives in your head.
  • Cash is tight. You need to carry the pay for several months while they learn.
  • You want them to fix a people problem you won't face. A manager can't fix a person you have not dealt with yourself.
  • You won't let go. If you plan to check every call they make, you will pay for a manager and still do the job.

None of these is a reason to give up. They are the first jobs on the list.

What should your first manager do?

Your first manager should own a set of decisions, not just a list of tasks. That is the difference between a helper and a manager.

In a small firm, the first manager is often one of these:

  • A field lead or operations manager. Runs the schedule, the crews and the day-to-day jobs. Common in trade firms.
  • An office or practice manager. Runs the front desk, the staff schedule, billing and vendors. Common in dental and orthopedic practices.
  • A second-in-command. A broader role: the person who runs the business day to day while you work on sales, pricing and the future.

Write a one-page job sheet before you post the job or talk to anyone. List what they decide alone, what they decide with you, and what stays with you for now.

Should you promote from within or hire from outside?

Promote from within when someone already has the trust of the team and wants to lead. Hire from outside when no one does, or when you need skills no one on the team has.

Be careful with the obvious pick. Your strongest tech or your fastest hygienist is good at the work. Managing is a different job. Gallup's research finds that about one in 10 people have high talent to manage. It also finds that companies fail to choose the person with the right talent for the job 82% of the time. It is easy to promote someone because they earned it, not because they fit the role.

This choice matters more than it looks. Gallup finds that managers account for at least 70% of the difference in how engaged a team is. A weak manager can drive off the good people you hired them to keep.

Promote from within

Hire from outside

Knows your jobs, your customers and your crew

Brings skills and habits from other firms

Team already knows them

Starts with no history, good or bad

May struggle to boss former peers

Needs time to learn how you work

You lose a strong worker on the tools

Costs more to find

Whichever way you go, ask the person to describe a time they had to tell a peer something hard. Their answer tells you more than their skills do.

Can you afford a manager?

You can afford a manager if the hours you get back go into work that brings in money. If you spend them on more of the same, the manager is only a cost.

Start with labor cost. A manager's labor cost is more than the pay. It also includes payroll taxes and the other costs of having someone on staff. Ask your CPA what the full cost of the role looks like for your business before you hire.

Then list what you would do with a day or two back each week. Good answers are things like:

  • Price jobs properly instead of rushing quotes.
  • Win larger or better customers.
  • Fix cash flow, so you are not waiting on slow payers.
  • Train the next layer of leads. Building people up this way is called leadership development.

One number to watch is revenue per employee. That is your total sales for the year divided by the number of people on staff. If you add a manager and that number keeps falling a year later, the role is not paying its way yet.

How do you hand off work without losing control?

You hand off work by handing off decisions with clear limits, then checking in on a set schedule. Control comes from limits and a weekly review, not from doing it all yourself.

Start with five steps:

  1. Write it down. The things everyone "just knows" but no one wrote down are called institutional knowledge. Getting them on paper is called knowledge capture. It turns your know-how into checklists, so it is not lost when you are out. Start with the ten questions you answer most.
  2. Set the limits. For example: the manager can approve a change order up to a set amount, move the schedule, and handle a customer complaint. Bigger calls still come to you.
  3. Meet each week. Thirty minutes. What moved? What is stuck? What needs you?
  4. Watch a few numbers. Jobs done, jobs waiting, callbacks or redo work, and cash in the bank.
  5. Step back in stages. Take one day off the tools, then a week away. Fix what breaks.

Hand off first

Keep for now

The daily schedule

Prices and big quotes

Crew or staff questions

Hiring and firing

Supply orders and vendors

Bank and loan decisions

Routine customer calls

Your largest customers

We cover this in more detail in our guide to how to make your business run without you.

A worked example

For example, picture a 12-person landscaping company. This is an invented example, not a client. Dan owns it and runs three crews. He bids every job, answers every crew call and does the books on Sunday night.

Dan's lead on crew one, Maria, has been with him six years. The crews trust her. Dan writes a one-page sheet: Maria runs the daily schedule, handles crew questions and orders supplies. She can approve small changes on a job. Prices, hiring and the bank stay with Dan.

For the first month, they meet every morning for 15 minutes. After that, once a week. Dan uses his new time to price spring work earlier and follow up on old quotes. Three months in, Dan takes his first week off in years. Two things break. They fix both and add them to the checklist.

That is the pattern: write it down, set the limits, meet often, then step back.

What we look at

When we look at a business's growth, the first question is often who makes the decisions. A business coach or consultant can help you see that from the outside. In Discovery, we map where your week goes and which decisions only you can make. Then we help you decide which role to hire first and what it should own. You can read how we look at Growth, and how Discovery works.

Hiring the right person is its own job. We cover it in how to hire and keep good people. And if you plan to use your new hours on sales, read how to get more of the right customers.

Your CPA or payroll service sets up the new salary and the taxes on it. Your lawyer can review an offer letter if it includes anything beyond pay and hours.

Talk it through

Altus Financial is a business coaching firm in Northampton, MA. We work with all kinds of service firms. Some are trade and contracting businesses. Some are practices.

If you are not sure whether it is time for a manager, talk it through with us. A Founders Call takes 20 to 30 minutes. Book a Founders Call.

Sources

  1. About one in 10 people possess high talent to manage Gallup, "Few People Possess the Talent to Manage" (Workplace, April 13, 2015)
  2. Companies fail to choose the candidate with the right talent for the job 82% of the time Gallup, same article (April 13, 2015)
  3. Managers account for at least 70% of the variance in employee engagement scores Gallup, "Managers Account for 70% of Variance in Employee Engagement" (Harter and Adkins, April 8, 2015)

Questions

Frequently asked.

When should a small business hire its first manager?

Hire your first manager when jobs wait on your answer, the same problems keep coming back, and the work only you can do keeps slipping. The number of people matters less than where your hours go. If you can't take a week off without things breaking, you are likely past the point where one person can hold it all.

Should I promote an employee to manager or hire from outside?

Promote from within when someone has the team's trust and wants to lead. Hire from outside when no one does, or you need new skills. Be careful with your strongest worker. Gallup finds only about one in 10 people have high talent to manage. Managing is a different job from doing the work.

How do I delegate without losing control?

Hand off decisions with clear limits, not just tasks. Write down how the work is done. Say what the manager decides alone and what still comes to you. Then meet each week and watch a few numbers. Control comes from those limits and the weekly check-in, not from doing every job yourself.

What does a first manager do in a small business?

A first manager owns a set of decisions. In a trade firm, that is often the schedule, the crews and day-to-day jobs. In a practice, it is often the front desk, the staff schedule, billing and vendors. Write a one-page job sheet first, listing what they decide alone and what stays with you for now.

How do I know if I can afford a manager?

You can afford one if the hours you get back go into work that brings in money, like pricing, sales and fixing cash flow. Ask your CPA for the full cost of the role, not just the pay. A year later, check whether revenue per employee held up. If it keeps falling, the role is not paying its way yet.

Keep Reading

Talk to a consultant

Got a question about your own business?

Start with a short call. It takes 20 to 30 minutes, and we both work out if we can help.

Important information

The content on this website is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended as, and should not be relied upon as, legal, tax, accounting, or investment advice.

Individual circumstances vary. You should consult your own attorney and CPA before acting on any information presented here. Altus Financial does not draft legal documents, give legal advice, or render tax or accounting opinions.