Benjamin Minifie
When to Hire Your First Manager
ReadHire your first manager when you have become the thing that slows the business down. Where your hours go matters more than how many people you have.
Benjamin Minifie· Draft
To get more of the right customers, decide who they are. Then make it easy for them to find you and say yes. And keep the ones you have.
To get more of the right customers, decide who they are. Then make it easy for them to find you and say yes, and keep the ones you already have. More leads of the wrong kind just fill your week with low-profit work. The aim is steadier work from people who pay your price and send their friends.
Many owners start with ads. Ads can help, but they work better after the basics are in place. This guide walks through the basics, in order.
The right customer pays your price, pays on time, and gives you work you do well. They are also in your area and likely to call you again or send someone.
To find them, pull last year's jobs. Sort them by profit, not by size. Then look at the top 20 and ask:
You will often see a pattern. Maybe your profit comes from service work, not new installs. Maybe it comes from two towns, or from repeat commercial customers. That is who you want more of. If you don't know which jobs make money, start by learning to work out your profit per job.
Pricing matters here too. If your prices are too low, more customers just means more work for less. Read how contractors set markup before you chase volume.
You get more customers by keeping the ones you have and asking them for referrals. Then get found locally, and follow up on every quote. The five steps below are in the order we would start.
1. Keep the customers you have. This is called customer retention. A past customer already trusts you. Call them back for a check-up, send a reminder when service is due, and offer a yearly service plan. Fred Reichheld of Bain, who has studied customer loyalty for years, has written that small increases in keeping customers soon turn into big boosts to profit.
2. Ask for referrals. Happy customers will often send people your way if you ask. More on this below.
3. Get found locally. When someone searches "electrician near me," you want to show up. Your Google Business Profile does much of this work.
4. Follow up on every quote. Some quotes are lost only because no one called back. A call two days later and a note a week later cost you little. Track which ones you won.
5. Make it easy to say yes. Answer the phone, or call back the same day when you can. Send quotes fast. Make them clear, with no surprises.
Marketing is anything that helps the right people find you and pick you. Ads, a website, a truck wrap and a yard sign all count. But the five steps above are where many service firms have room to improve.
You get more referrals by asking at the right moment, making it easy, and thanking people who send them. Referrals are strong because people trust people. In Nielsen's 2021 Trust in Advertising study, 88% of people said they trust recommendations from people they know. That was the most trusted source in the study, ahead of every kind of ad.
These steps tend to work:
Write down who sends you work. After a year, you will know which partners matter most, and who to take to lunch.
You get found locally by keeping your Google Business Profile full and current, and by earning reviews. Google says local results are based mainly on three things:
Factor | What it means | What you can do |
|---|---|---|
Relevance | How well your profile matches the search | Pick the right category, list your services, add photos |
Distance | How close you are to the person searching | Set your service area correctly |
Popularity | How well known your business is | Earn reviews, and reply to them |
Google also says more reviews and positive ratings can help your local ranking. And it says that replying to reviews shows you value feedback. Reply to the bad ones too, calmly and briefly.
One rule to know: don't buy reviews. In 2024, the Federal Trade Commission finalized a rule on fake reviews. Among other things, it bars businesses from paying or giving perks for reviews that must say something good, or something bad. Asking every customer for an honest review is fine.
You build a steady pipeline by keeping one list of every lead and quote, and looking at it each week. A sales pipeline is just that list, sorted by stage. When you can see it, you can see slow months coming before they arrive.
Stage | What it means |
|---|---|
New lead | Someone called, emailed or filled in a form |
Visit or call | You have talked and seen the job |
Quote sent | They have a price in hand |
Follow-up | You have checked back at least once |
Won or lost | Write down which, and why |
A spreadsheet works. Field service software like ServiceTitan or Buildertrend can track this too, if you already use one. The tool matters less than the weekly habit.
Watch two numbers:
Repeat work smooths out the year. Service plans, yearly check-ups and seasonal work booked ahead give you a floor to build on. That also helps your cash flow, because you can see what is coming.
Spend what a customer is worth to you, and no more. To know that, you need two numbers.
The first is customer acquisition cost, or CAC. It is what you spent on marketing and sales in a period, divided by the number of new customers you won in that period. The second is the profit a customer brings, over all the jobs they give you, not just the first one.
If a customer brings far more profit than it cost to win them, spend more on that source. If not, cut it. Do this for each source: ads, lead services, mailers, referrals. Count referrals and past customers as sources too.
For example, picture a 6-person electrical shop. This is an invented example, not a client. Pete owns it. Last year he tried two ways to win new customers. When he added it up, he found this:
Source | Spent last year | New customers | Cost per new customer (CAC) |
|---|---|---|---|
Paid lead service | $6,000 | 20 | $300 |
Thank-you notes and referral cards | $600 | 15 | $40 |
The lead service brought more customers. But many were one-time jobs, shopping on price. The referral customers paid his price, and several called back for more work. Pete kept a small amount on the lead service and put more time into asking for referrals and following up on quotes.
These numbers are made up to show the math. Yours will differ. The point is to measure each source, not to guess.
When we look at Growth, we start with who your right customer is and where your profit really comes from. Then we look at how work comes in, how quotes are followed up, and how much comes back from past customers. You can read how we look at Growth, and how Discovery works.
More customers also means more work to do. If the crew is already stretched, read how to hire and keep good people, and when to hire your first manager.
Altus Financial is a business coaching firm in Northampton, MA. We work with all kinds of service firms, from trades to practices.
If work comes in waves and you want it steadier, talk it through with us. A Founders Call takes 20 to 30 minutes. Book a Founders Call.
Questions
Start by deciding who your right customer is: someone who pays your price, pays on time and comes back. Then keep the customers you have, ask them for referrals, keep your Google Business Profile current, and follow up on every quote. Ads can help, but they work better once those basics are in place.
Ask right after a job goes well, when the customer is thanking you. Make it easy with two cards or a text they can forward. Thank everyone who sends work your way. Build links with other trades and suppliers, who see jobs you don't. Write down who refers you so you know which partners matter.
Keep one list of every lead and quote, sorted by stage: new lead, visit, quote sent, follow-up, and won or lost. Look at it every week. Watch your close rate and how many weeks of work are booked ahead. Repeat work, like service plans, gives you a steady floor.
Customer acquisition cost, or CAC, is what you spent on marketing and sales in a period divided by the new customers you won in that period. Work it out for each source, like ads or referrals. Then compare it with the profit a customer brings over time, and spend more on the sources that pay.
Keep your Google Business Profile full and up to date. Google says local results turn on how well you match the search, how close you are, and how well known you are. Pick the right category, list your services and set your service area. Ask every customer for an honest review, and reply to them. Never pay for good ones.
Keep Reading
Benjamin Minifie
Hire your first manager when you have become the thing that slows the business down. Where your hours go matters more than how many people you have.
Benjamin Minifie
A business coach helps you see how your business runs. Then they help you pick what to fix first, and keep at it.
Benjamin Minifie
Your markup has to cover your overhead and leave a profit. For the average remodeler, that works out to about 43% on job cost, not 20%.
Talk to a consultant
Start with a short call. It takes 20 to 30 minutes, and we both work out if we can help.
Important information
The content on this website is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended as, and should not be relied upon as, legal, tax, accounting, or investment advice.
Individual circumstances vary. You should consult your own attorney and CPA before acting on any information presented here. Altus Financial does not draft legal documents, give legal advice, or render tax or accounting opinions.