Benjamin Minifie
When to Hire Your First Manager
ReadHire your first manager when you have become the thing that slows the business down. Where your hours go matters more than how many people you have.
Benjamin Minifie· Draft
Profit per job is the price of the job minus everything it cost you to do it, including a fair share of your overhead. Most owners leave out that last part.
To work out your profit per job, take the price of the job and subtract what it cost you to do it. That means the parts and materials, the labor at its true cost, any other costs tied to that job, and a fair share of your overhead. What is left is the profit the job really made. Divide it by the price to get your profit margin on that job.
Most owners do the first half. They take the price, subtract parts and wages, and call the rest profit. That leaves out what labor really costs and what it costs to keep the doors open. So the job looks better on paper than it was.
Use four steps. Do them the same way on every job, so you can compare one to another.
Line | Formula |
|---|---|
Gross profit | Price − job costs |
Gross margin | Gross profit ÷ price |
Overhead share | Billable hours on the job × overhead rate |
Net job profit | Gross profit − overhead share |
Net job margin | Net job profit ÷ price |
The two steps owners most often get wrong are the cost of labor and the share of overhead. Both are below.
An hour of labor costs you the wage plus benefits and payroll taxes, spread over only the hours you can bill. That is usually a lot more than the wage alone.
Start with what you pay on top of the wage. In June 2026, private employers paid an average of about 43 cents in benefits for every dollar of wages, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Wages were 70% of what employers spent on their people. Benefits, which here include paid time off and payroll taxes, were the other 30%. Your own number will be different. Your bookkeeper or CPA can pull it from your payroll reports. Some owners call it the labor burden.
Then look at billable hours. A tech who is paid for eight hours may only bill six. The rest goes to driving, loading the truck, picking up parts and meetings. Those hours still cost you money. So the real cost of a billable hour is higher again.
To work it out:
That is the labor cost per billable hour. Use it in your job costs, not the hourly wage.
The simplest way is an overhead rate per billable hour. Add up last year's overhead. Divide it by the total billable hours your whole crew worked. Then charge each job that rate for every hour it used.
This is not the only way to do it, but it is simple and it is fair to most service work. A job that takes two days of crew time uses more of the business than a job that takes two hours. If your work is very parts-heavy, you can ask your CPA about spreading overhead by job cost instead.
Do this math once a year, and again if your overhead or your crew size changes a lot. If you add an office hire, your overhead rate goes up the day they start.
This is a made-up example. It is not a client.
For example, a plumbing company has four techs. First it works out its two rates from last year's numbers.
Rate | How it is worked out | Result |
|---|---|---|
Labor cost per billable hour | $30 wage + 43% benefits and payroll taxes = $42.90, divided by 75% of hours billed | $57 |
Overhead per billable hour | $360,000 overhead ÷ 6,000 billable hours (4 techs × 1,500) | $60 |
Then it looks at one job, a water heater swap priced at a flat rate. The estimate said four tech hours. The job took seven, because the old fittings did not match and a tech went back to the supply house.
Water heater job | Estimate | Actual |
|---|---|---|
Price | $3,200 | $3,200 |
Parts and fittings | $1,400 | $1,480 |
Labor at $57 per billable hour | $228 (4 hours) | $399 (7 hours) |
Permit and haul-away | $150 | $150 |
Gross profit | $1,422 (44%) | $1,171 (37%) |
Overhead at $60 per billable hour | $240 | $420 |
Net job profit | $1,182 (37%) | $751 (23%) |
The job still made money. But it made about a third less than the estimate said. The cause was not the price. It was three extra hours and a second trip.
If that happens on one job in five, it is a small leak. If it happens on most of them, it is a pricing problem. The fix might be a better parts check before the job, a higher flat rate, or a line in the price for older homes.
Use the same steps as a single job, but for a whole year. Your gross margin is your yearly sales minus all job costs, divided by sales. Your net profit margin is your net income divided by your sales. Net income is what is left after every cost, both job costs and overhead.
Both numbers are on your profit and loss statement, if your bookkeeper sorts costs into job costs and overhead. If they do not, ask them to. It is the only way the P&L can tell you anything about your jobs.
Then compare the two. If gross margin is fine but net margin is thin, look at overhead. If gross margin itself is thin, look at prices and job costs. To see how your numbers stack up, read what a good profit margin is for your kind of work.
A job loses money when the hours or costs run past what the price allowed for. The usual causes are:
Check a few jobs every month, and every large job when it closes. You do not need to do every small call. Pick a few of each kind of work and compare what you estimated to what happened.
The point is the gap between the estimate and the actual. A steady gap tells you your estimates are off. Job costing software, like the job tools in QuickBooks, ServiceTitan or Buildertrend, can do the math for you. But only if your crew logs hours and parts to the right job. The habit matters more than the tool.
The same idea works outside the trades. In a dental or orthopedic practice, the "job" might be one type of appointment, or one hour of the schedule. The steps do not change: price, direct costs, a share of overhead.
Altus Financial is a business coaching firm in Northampton, MA. Job profit is part of how we look at Savings. It is one of the four areas we work in.
In the Discovery step, we work out your true labor cost and overhead rate with you. Then we look at a year of jobs by kind of work, so you can see what really pays. For trade firms, there is more on coaching for trade owners.
Your CPA keeps the books and handles the taxes. We work alongside them, using the numbers they already keep.
Job profit and cash are two different things. A job can make a good profit and still leave you short on payday. That is covered in why profit is not cash.
Want to know what your jobs really make? Book a Founders Call. It takes 20 to 30 minutes.
Questions
Take the price of the job. Subtract parts and materials, labor at its true cost, and other costs tied to that job. That gives you gross profit. Then subtract the job's share of overhead, using an overhead rate per billable hour. What is left is net job profit. Divide it by the price for the margin.
Anything you would not have spent without the job. That means parts and materials, labor hours at their full cost, subs, rented equipment, permits and dump fees. Rent, office staff, phones and software are overhead, not job costs. Each job carries a share of overhead through your overhead rate instead.
Add up last year's overhead. Divide it by the total hours your crew billed to jobs. That gives you overhead per billable hour. Charge each job that rate for every hour it used. Redo the math once a year, or sooner if you add staff, trucks or space.
Gross profit is the price minus the job's own costs: parts, labor and other direct costs. Net profit also takes out the job's share of overhead. A job can show a healthy gross profit and still make little or nothing once it carries its fair part of the cost of running the business.
Check every large job when it closes, and a few smaller jobs of each kind every month. Compare the estimate to what really happened. One job running over is normal. The same kind of job running over again and again means your estimates or your prices need to change.
Keep Reading
Benjamin Minifie
Hire your first manager when you have become the thing that slows the business down. Where your hours go matters more than how many people you have.
Stanislav Lisovskiy
A business exit strategy is your plan for how you will leave the business, and when. You pick the way out years ahead, so it does not pick you.
Benjamin Minifie
A business coach helps you see how your business runs. Then they help you pick what to fix first, and keep at it.
Talk to a consultant
Start with a short call. It takes 20 to 30 minutes, and we both work out if we can help.
Important information
The content on this website is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended as, and should not be relied upon as, legal, tax, accounting, or investment advice.
Individual circumstances vary. You should consult your own attorney and CPA before acting on any information presented here. Altus Financial does not draft legal documents, give legal advice, or render tax or accounting opinions.