Benjamin Minifie
When to Hire Your First Manager
ReadHire your first manager when you have become the thing that slows the business down. Where your hours go matters more than how many people you have.
Benjamin Minifie· Draft
A good profit margin depends on which margin you mean. In two national studies, remodelers and home builders kept about 6% to 9% net.
What is a good profit margin for a small business? It depends on which margin you mean, and on your trade. Gross margin is what is left after you pay for the jobs. Net margin is what is left after you also pay to run the company. In national studies from the home builders' association, remodelers kept about 6% net and home builders about 9%. Your own numbers matter more than any average.
There are two margins worth knowing.
Gross margin is what you keep after the cost of the work itself. Labor on the job, materials, and subs. It tells you if you price jobs well.
Net margin is what you keep after everything. That includes overhead: trucks, the office, phones, software, admin staff, and your own pay if it is not in job costs. It tells you if the company as a whole makes money.
Both are a percent of what you bring in.
A business can have a strong gross margin and still lose money, if overhead eats it.
The National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) studies what it costs to run a home building or remodeling firm. These are its latest averages:
| Gross margin | Overhead | Net margin |
|---|---|---|---|
Remodelers (2024) | 29.9% | 23.6% of revenue | 6.3% |
Home builders (2023) | 20.7% | 12.0% of revenue | 8.7% |
Look at what happens. Remodelers kept more on each job: about 30 cents of every dollar, against about 21 for builders. But their overhead was about twice as high. So they ended up with less at the bottom.
That is the lesson for any trade. Gross margin is about pricing. Net margin is about running the company. You need both to be healthy.
Revenue tells you how busy you are. Margin tells you if being busy pays. Two companies can each bill a million dollars a year. One keeps 10 cents of each dollar. The other keeps 2 cents. The first can pay its people well, fix its trucks and save for a slow winter. The second is one bad month away from a loan.
That is why growing sales alone can make things worse. If each job loses a little, more jobs lose more. Check the margin before you chase the next big contract.
They use the same numbers, but they divide by different things. Markup is how much you add on top of your cost. Margin is how much of the price you keep. A job that costs you $1,000 and sells for $1,500 has a 50% markup. But its margin is only 33%, because you keep $500 of the $1,500.
This mix-up costs owners money. If you want a 50% margin and you add a 50% markup, you will fall short every time. Our guide to general contractor markup shows how to set a markup that gives you the margin you want.
Many online guides say a 5% net margin is low, 10% is healthy, and 20% is high. It is a fair rough guide. But it is a rule of thumb, not a study. And it mixes very different businesses together.
So ask a different question. Is your margin going up or down, and why? Your own numbers, month to month, tell you more than any national average.
It depends which margin. A 50% gross margin can be normal for a service business with low material costs. A 50% net margin would be rare for a small business.
If your gross margin is high but your net is thin, look at overhead. If your gross margin is low, look at pricing and job costs first.
You need three numbers from last year. Your bookkeeper or CPA can pull them from your profit and loss statement.
Then work out both margins with the formulas above. Do it again each month. One year is a snapshot. Twelve months is a trend.
If you can, check the gross margin on each kind of work too. Sometimes one type of job carries the business, and another quietly loses money.
Check them once a month, and look at the trend. One month can fool you. A big job that closes late, or a slow winter, will swing the numbers. Twelve months in a row tell you the truth.
Ask your bookkeeper for a simple report each month. It needs revenue, job costs and overhead. Then work out both margins and write them down. If the gross margin drops, look at your last few bids. If the net margin drops but gross holds, look at what grew in overhead.
This is a made-up example. It is not a client.
A plumbing company billed $1,500,000 last year.
Gross margin = ($1,500,000 − $1,050,000) ÷ $1,500,000 = 30%
Net margin = ($1,500,000 − $1,050,000 − $390,000) ÷ $1,500,000 = 4%
The gross margin looks fine, close to the remodelers' average. But overhead is 26% of revenue, so the company keeps only 4 cents of every dollar. The owner's next questions are about overhead, not pricing. What grew last year? A second truck? A new office hire? Is each of those paying for itself?
There is no single fix, and nothing here is a promise. Here are good places to look first:
Change one thing at a time, so you can see what worked.
Then protect it. Costs creep up a little each year. Wages rise, fuel rises, and the software bill grows. If your prices stay put, your margin shrinks without anyone noticing. Look at your prices at least once a year. A good margin also gives you choices. You can pay your key people more, save for a slow season or put money back into the business.
Altus Financial is a business coaching firm in Northampton, MA. Margins are part of Savings. It is one of the four areas we work in.
In Discovery, we look at a year of your numbers by kind of work, so you can see what really pays. Then we work through the fixes with you, and track your margins each month.
We don't do your accounting. Your CPA does, and your CPA handles the taxes. We work alongside them.
Want to talk through your numbers? Book a Founders Call. It takes 20 to 30 minutes.
Questions
It depends on the margin and the trade. Online guides often call 10% net healthy. That is a rule of thumb. In national NAHB studies, remodelers kept about 6% net and home builders about 9%. Your own margins, tracked monthly, tell you more than any average.
In NAHB's latest studies, remodelers averaged a 29.9% gross margin and a 6.3% net margin. Home builders averaged 20.7% gross and 8.7% net. Remodelers kept more per job but spent more on overhead, so they ended up with less at the bottom.
Gross margin is what you keep after the cost of the work itself: job labor, materials and subs. Net margin is what you keep after overhead too, like trucks, the office and admin staff. Gross margin is about pricing. Net margin is about running the company.
It depends which margin. A 50% gross margin can be normal for a service business with low material costs. A 50% net margin would be rare for a small business. If gross is high but net is thin, the place to look is overhead.
There is no single fix. Start by finding where it leaks. Check prices against job costs, track labor and materials on each job, and look at which kinds of work really pay. Then check each overhead cost against what it brings in. Change one thing at a time so you can see what worked.
Keep Reading
Benjamin Minifie
Hire your first manager when you have become the thing that slows the business down. Where your hours go matters more than how many people you have.
Stanislav Lisovskiy
A business exit strategy is your plan for how you will leave the business, and when. You pick the way out years ahead, so it does not pick you.
Benjamin Minifie
A business coach helps you see how your business runs. Then they help you pick what to fix first, and keep at it.
Talk to a consultant
Start with a short call. It takes 20 to 30 minutes, and we both work out if we can help.
Important information
The content on this website is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended as, and should not be relied upon as, legal, tax, accounting, or investment advice.
Individual circumstances vary. You should consult your own attorney and CPA before acting on any information presented here. Altus Financial does not draft legal documents, give legal advice, or render tax or accounting opinions.