Benjamin Minifie
When to Hire Your First Manager
ReadHire your first manager when you have become the thing that slows the business down. Where your hours go matters more than how many people you have.
Benjamin Minifie· Draft
Pay yourself a steady wage for the work you do, close to what you would pay someone else to do it. Then take a share of the profit on top, but only when the cash is there.
A small business owner should pay themselves a steady wage for the work they do, set close to what they would pay someone else to do that job. On top of that, take a share of the profit, but only after the business has set aside money for taxes and kept a cash cushion. The wage pays you for working. The profit pays you for owning.
Many owners do neither on purpose. They take whatever is left at the end of the month. That feels fine in a good month. In a bad month, you go without, or you take money the business needed for payroll.
Pay yourself about what you would have to pay someone else to do your job. That is often called a market wage, or a fair wage.
Start by naming the job. Most owners do more than one. You may bid the work, run the schedule, manage the crew and keep the books. Pick the main one, the one you would hire for first if you stepped back. For many owners, that is a general manager.
The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports what that job paid across the US:
Job | Middle (median) yearly pay, US, May 2025 |
|---|---|
General and operations managers | $105,770 |
That number is a national middle. Half of these managers earn more, and half earn less. Pay for the same job changes a lot with where you are and how big the business is. Use it as a check, not a rule. Local job ads for the same role, or your CPA, can show you what it pays near you.
If you also do hands-on work, like running a crew or doing the work yourself in a practice, you are doing two jobs. Price the one you would replace first.
Paying yourself a fair wage shows you what the business really makes. If you pay yourself too little, the profit looks bigger than it is. If you pay yourself too much, the business looks weaker than it is.
This matters most on the day you want to step back. Picture hiring a manager to do your job. The business would have to pay them a fair wage, every two weeks, in good months and slow ones. If the business can only make a profit because you work for less than that, it is not ready to run without you. Read about making your business run without you.
A buyer looks at it the same way. They ask what the business would earn if they paid someone to do your job. That is one reason owner pay shows up in what drives what it's worth.
Then the business has a pricing or cost problem, and your low pay is hiding it. In the first year or two, a low wage can be part of getting started. After that, it is a sign.
Look at three things first:
Set a date by which the business should pay you a fair wage. Then work back from it.
That depends on how your business is set up, and it is a tax question for your CPA. A salary is a wage you get through payroll. An owner's draw is money you take out of the business that is not a wage.
The IRS says two things here. Partners are not staff, so they should not get a W-2 for their share. And if you run a corporation as one of its officers, your wage should generally match the work you do. Sole owners, partners, LLC members and officers are each paid a bit differently. Each way is taxed in its own way.
Your CPA works out which way fits you, how much to set aside for taxes, and when it is due. Get that answer in writing before you change how you pay yourself.
This is a made-up example. It is not a client.
For example, Mike owns an electrical company with eight electricians. He pays himself a small wage, and takes extra money out when the bank account looks good. On paper, his business makes a strong profit.
Mike runs the business as its general manager. So he prices his job at a fair wage for that role, rounded down from the national middle above.
Last year | As the books show it | With a fair wage for Mike's job |
|---|---|---|
Sales | $1,800,000 | $1,800,000 |
Job costs and overhead, not counting Mike | $1,530,000 | $1,530,000 |
Mike's wage | $60,000 | $105,000 |
Profit | $210,000 | $165,000 |
The business is still healthy. But its real profit is lower than the books showed, because Mike was working for less than his job is worth. That matters if Mike ever wants a manager to run it, or wants to sell.
So Mike makes two changes. He puts the fair wage on payroll, every two weeks. Then, once a quarter, he looks at the profit, sets aside his CPA's tax estimate, keeps his cash cushion, and takes a share of the rest. His total pay may end up about the same. But now the business can see what it costs to run, and Mike can see what it really makes.
Altus Financial is a business coaching firm in Northampton, MA. Owner pay is part of how we look at Savings, and it ties into who runs the business next.
In the Discovery step, we look at what you take out, what your job would cost to fill, and whether the business can carry both. If the answer is not yet, we work on the prices and costs behind it with you. When the time comes to hand off part of your job, we help you plan when to hire your first manager.
Your CPA handles how you are paid and the taxes on it. We work alongside them.
Not sure what you should be taking home? Book a Founders Call. It takes 20 to 30 minutes.
Questions
Pay yourself a steady wage close to what you would pay someone else to do your job. Then take a share of the profit on top, but only after you set aside money for taxes and keep a cash cushion. The wage pays you for working. The profit pays you for owning the business.
There is no set percentage that fits every business. Start with a fair wage for your job, paid on a schedule. Then each quarter, look at the profit, set aside your CPA's tax estimate and keep a cash cushion. What is left can be shared out to you or kept to grow the business.
It depends on how your business is set up, and it is a tax question for your CPA. A salary comes through payroll. A draw is money you take out that is not a wage. Your CPA can tell you which fits, how much to hold back for taxes and when it is due.
In the first year or two, many owners take a low wage while the business finds its feet. After that, a business that cannot pay you a fair wage has a price or cost problem. Look at your prices, your profit per job and your overhead, and set a date to fix it.
Because whoever takes over will have to pay someone to do your job. If the business only makes a profit because you work for less than your job is worth, its real profit is lower than the books say. Paying yourself a fair wage shows what the business truly makes.
Keep Reading
Benjamin Minifie
Hire your first manager when you have become the thing that slows the business down. Where your hours go matters more than how many people you have.
Stanislav Lisovskiy
A business exit strategy is your plan for how you will leave the business, and when. You pick the way out years ahead, so it does not pick you.
Benjamin Minifie
A business coach helps you see how your business runs. Then they help you pick what to fix first, and keep at it.
Talk to a consultant
Start with a short call. It takes 20 to 30 minutes, and we both work out if we can help.
Important information
The content on this website is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended as, and should not be relied upon as, legal, tax, accounting, or investment advice.
Individual circumstances vary. You should consult your own attorney and CPA before acting on any information presented here. Altus Financial does not draft legal documents, give legal advice, or render tax or accounting opinions.